FREE SHIPPING on orders over $100
Cookies
Collections
Platters
Baking Mixes
Subscriptions & Gift Cards!
The 2026 Fall Cookie Collection (6 Cookies)
$55.00 ( / )
Halloween DIY Cookie Decorating Kit
$50.00 ( / )
Maya's Signature DIY Cookie Decorating Kit
$45.00 ( / )
Special Occasion Gift Bundle
$65.00 ( / )
Create Your Own Box: 6-8 Cookies
$0.00 ( / )
Classic Collection (6 Cookies)
Premium Collection (6 Cookies)
$60.00 ( / )
Maya's Signature Collection (12 Cookies)
$75.00 ( / )
Wheat Free Collection (6 Cookies)
Birthday Cake (6 Cookies)
Brown Sugar Butterscotch (6 Cookies)
Caramel Pecan (6 Cookies)
Chocolate Chip S'mores (6 Cookies)
Classic Chocolate Chip (6 Cookies)
Double Chocolate Chunk (6 Cookies)
Drunken Grandma (6 Cookies)
Famous "Everything" Cookie (6 Cookies)
Lemon Chiffon (6 cookies)
Marble Fudge (6 Cookies)
Snickerdoodle (6 Cookies)
Sweet Cream Cold Brew (6 cookies)
Wheat Free Coconut Chocolate Chip (6 cookies)
Wheat Free Drunken Grandma (6 cookies)
Wheat Free Oatmeal Chocolate Chip (6 Cookies)
Cookie Love Club - Recurring Subscription
Cookie Love Club - Prepaid Subscription
Fall Collection Platter
$58.00 ( / )
Large Spring Platter - Sold Out!
$118.00 ( / )
Small Classic Cookie Platter
$59.00 ( / )
Large Classic Cookie Platter
